ourinsuranceworld.com
  • Business Insurance
    • General Liability Insurance
    • Professional Liability Insurance
    • Small Business Insurance
    • Workers Compensation Insurance
  • Car Insurance
    • RV Insurance
  • Health insurance
    • Dental Insurance
  • Holiday Insurance
  • Home Insurance
    • Condo Insurance
    • Flood Insurance
    • Homeowners Insurance
    • Pet Insurance
    • Renters Insurance
    • Umbrella Insurance
  • Travel Insurance
  • News
No Result
View All Result
  • Business Insurance
    • General Liability Insurance
    • Professional Liability Insurance
    • Small Business Insurance
    • Workers Compensation Insurance
  • Car Insurance
    • RV Insurance
  • Health insurance
    • Dental Insurance
  • Holiday Insurance
  • Home Insurance
    • Condo Insurance
    • Flood Insurance
    • Homeowners Insurance
    • Pet Insurance
    • Renters Insurance
    • Umbrella Insurance
  • Travel Insurance
  • News
No Result
View All Result
ourinsuranceworld.com
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

4th Circuit Issues Case, No Cryptocurrency Theft Coverage

Steven by Steven
22/11/2024
in News
4th Circuit Issues Case, No Cryptocurrency Theft Coverage
ADVERTISEMENT

A recent ruling by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has clarified that homeowners insurance policies do not cover the theft of cryptocurrency, as such losses do not meet the requirement of “direct physical loss” stipulated in the policy. This decision upholds a February 2023 ruling by a federal district court in Eastern Virginia favoring Lemonade Insurance.

Case Background

The case centers around Ali Sedaghatpour, who owned a significant amount of cryptocurrency stored in a hot wallet server called APYHarvest, located in Ireland and England. On December 31, 2021, Sedaghatpour discovered that his cryptocurrency, valued at approximately $170,424.67, had been stolen. He subsequently filed a claim under his homeowners insurance policy with Lemonade for the policy limit of $160,000.

ADVERTISEMENT

Insurance Claim and Denial

Lemonade denied the claim, arguing that the policy only covers property that has been “damaged directly” by specific losses, including theft. They contended that cryptocurrency, being a digital asset, does not involve any physical damage, thus failing to meet the “direct physical loss” requirement. Additionally, Lemonade pointed out that even if the loss were covered, the policy limited coverage for theft of electronic funds to $500, an amount they subsequently paid to Sedaghatpour.

ADVERTISEMENT

Legal Proceedings

Sedaghatpour sued Lemonade, and the district court initially dismissed his complaint but allowed him to amend it to provide more details about the stolen cryptocurrencies. His amended complaint specified the types of cryptocurrencies stolen and alleged that APYHarvest was involved in the theft by transferring the assets to a company in the Cayman Islands, Binance.com, and subsequently selling them.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite these details, Lemonade moved to dismiss the amended complaint, reiterating that the policy does not cover cryptocurrency losses and that any potential coverage would be limited to $500.

Court Rulings

The main question for the court was whether the theft of cryptocurrency constituted a “direct physical loss” under the insurance policy. The court concluded that cryptocurrency exists only in a virtual or digital form and lacks any physical or tangible existence. Thus, it determined that the loss of cryptocurrency does not qualify as a “direct physical loss” to property, which is a prerequisite for coverage under the policy.

The court referenced previous case law, including a 2003 Fourth Circuit case involving Hartford Insurance, which established that a “direct physical loss” requires some form of physical impact to the insured property. In that case, the deletion of files from a computer constituted a direct physical loss because it caused damage to the plaintiff’s property. However, in Sedaghatpour’s case, the theft of cryptocurrency did not damage any physical property he owned, reinforcing the court’s conclusion.

Conclusion

The Fourth Circuit upheld the district court’s ruling, affirming that homeowners insurance policies do not cover losses related to cryptocurrency theft due to the lack of physical loss. This decision underscores the challenges faced by cryptocurrency holders in securing insurance coverage for their digital assets and highlights the need for insurance products specifically tailored to address the unique nature of cryptocurrencies.

Related Topics:

  • Hurricane Helene Exposes Flaws in U.S. Insurance System
  • ACIL Calls for Stronger Overhaul of Insurance Code
  • Belgium’s Ageas Enters Exclusive Talks for 20-Year Insurance Partnership with UK’s Saga
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

What Car Insurance Deductible Is Best?

Next Post

What Is The Best Travel Insurance For Backpackers?

Steven

Steven

Related Posts

OPTIS: Insurance M&A Falls 10%
News

OPTIS: Insurance M&A Falls 10%

26/11/2024
Marsh: US Rates Up 3%
News

Marsh: US Rates Up 3%

26/11/2024
Progressive Ends Fire Insurance
News

Progressive Ends Fire Insurance

26/11/2024
Zurich Insurance Sets New Goals
News

Zurich Insurance Sets New Goals

26/11/2024
4th Circuit: No Crypto Coverage
News

4th Circuit: No Crypto Coverage

26/11/2024
Safeco Buys Main Street
News

Safeco Buys Main Street

26/11/2024
Next Post
What Is The Best Travel Insurance For Backpackers?

What Is The Best Travel Insurance For Backpackers?

What Are The Different Types Of Travel Insurance?

What Are The Different Types Of Travel Insurance?

What Is Single Article Limit Travel Insurance?

What Is Single Article Limit Travel Insurance?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tags

Accidental Insurance Annual Travel Insurance barclays travel insurance campervan insurance cat insurance Commercial Property Insurance covid holiday insurance Credit Card Travel Insurance dog insurance dual Health Insurance full time rv insurance international health insurance jet2 holiday insurance landlord insurance Liability Car Insurance Malpractice Insurance Medical Travel Insurance military dental insurance natwest travel insurance nursing home insurance Personal Liability Insurance Personal Property Insurance Private Dental Insurance private flood insurance Private Health Insurance Progressive Rv Insurance Property Insurance Public Liability Insurance Rental Car Insurance Rental Property Insurance rv travel insurance ryanair travel insurance secondary dental insurance short term Health Insurance supplemental dental insurance third party liability pet insurance trailer insurance

Recent Posts

What Is Od Discount in Car Insurance
Car Insurance

What Is Od Discount in Car Insurance

by Steven
18/01/2025

Car insurance is an essential aspect of vehicle ownership, providing financial protection against accidents, theft, and other unforeseen events. One...

What Is Pa Cover in Motor Insurance

What Is Pa Cover in Motor Insurance

18/01/2025
What Is Subrogation in Car Insurance

What Is Subrogation in Car Insurance

18/01/2025
What Is Excess on Car Insurance

What Is Excess on Car Insurance

18/01/2025
What Is Ncb Discount in Car Insurance

What Is Ncb Discount in Car Insurance

18/01/2025
What Is Better Health Insurance Ppo or Hmo

What Is Better Health Insurance Ppo or Hmo

17/01/2025

Popular articles

Which Best Home Insurance Providers

Which Best Home Insurance Providers

27/12/2024
How to Get Workers Compensation Certificate

How to Get Workers Compensation Certificate

05/01/2025
Which Home Insurance Company Is Best at Paying Claims

Which Home Insurance Company Is Best at Paying Claims

28/12/2024
How Much Home Insurance Should You Buy

How Much Home Insurance Should You Buy

08/01/2025
Which Auto and Home Insurance Is the Best

Which Auto and Home Insurance Is the Best

27/12/2024
Is Workers Compensation Insurance Compulsory in Uae

Is Workers Compensation Insurance Compulsory in Uae

26/12/2024
ourinsuranceworld.com

Welcome to ourinsuranceworld ! We’re committed to offering personalized coverage that secures your future. With a focus on reliability and customer care, we strive to be your trusted partner in navigating life’s uncertainties.

Recent Posts

  • What Is Od Discount in Car Insurance 18/01/2025
  • What Is Pa Cover in Motor Insurance 18/01/2025
  • What Is Subrogation in Car Insurance 18/01/2025
  • What Is Excess on Car Insurance 18/01/2025
  • What Is Ncb Discount in Car Insurance 18/01/2025

TAGS

Accidental Insurance Annual Travel Insurance barclays travel insurance campervan insurance cat insurance cigna Health Insurance cobra Health Insurance Commercial Property Insurance covid holiday insurance Credit Card Travel Insurance dog insurance dual Health Insurance full time rv insurance international health insurance jet2 holiday insurance

Useful Links

about us

disclaimer

privacy policy

Copyright © 2024 ourinsuranceworld.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business Insurance
  • Car Insurance
  • Home Insurance
  • News

Copyright © 2024 Welcome to ourinsuranceworld ! We’re committed to offering personalized coverage that secures your future. With a focus on reliability and customer care, we strive to be your trusted partner in navigating life’s uncertainties.